Photo Booth Upload offers two 'modes' of AI rendering: Stable Diffusion and Gemini (Nano-Banana). These each have their own strengths and weaknesses. While there is no specific formula to determine when to use one option over the other, we recommend starting with Nana-Banana.
While Stable Diffusion is more literal (and slower), Gemini (NB) and Gemini (Pro) are more interpretive (and faster).
Below is a rough break-down of the strengths and weaknesses of each, but you will always need to experiment with prompts regardless of which option you choose:

Use Stable Diffusion when:
You want consistent, brand-aligned images
Prompts are pre-configured or professionally designed
Users expect high realism or specific styles
Use Gemini Nano-Banana when:
Ease of use is critical
You want to include specific text in the image (such as comic-book "POW")
The experience is playful, fast, and informal
Use Gemini Pro when:
You want faster results than Stable Diffusion, but more coherence than Nano-Banana
Users expect smarter interpretation (poses, scenes, moods, relationships between objects)
You’re building semi-polished experiences that still need speed
You want higher resolution images (up to 4K)
You want generative prompt renders that can be something other than square (such as Landscape and Portrait)